You agreed on a promotion plan with your manager and your skip-level. The expectations were clear, you were shipping what you promised, and the next level felt close. Then the reorg hit. Your manager moved to another division, your skip-level moved out of your reporting chain, and two new names appeared on your calendar. Nobody scheduled a meeting to cancel your plan. It simply stopped coming up in 1:1s, and the next performance review is already approaching.
Whether or not the promotion plan was written down, it rested partly on what two people who have moved on knew and remembered about your day-to-day work. Treat that plan, along with any written criteria, past reviews, and completed goals, as evidence to bring into the room, not a promise your new reporting chain inherits. Find out who now writes and argues your case (usually the new direct manager), who has to recognize your work when it is discussed (the new skip-level, and any calibration meeting or committee), and what the old plan actually rested on. Then put your evidence in a form someone who never saw the work can repeat, and ask the new manager early, well before the review, what they would need to see from you. Expect some reset. A new reader of your work can also judge it more generously than the old one did.
Work out who decides now
Ask your new manager directly, for your level under the current process, who recommends the promotion, who approves it, and whether a committee or calibration meeting takes part. You need actual names and roles, not org-chart theory. Don't assume that general promotion rules apply to your team without confirming who fills each seat.
In my post on who decides a staff promotion, I walked through the common corporate ladder mechanics where packets get assembled, vetted, and defended.
Your direct manager carries the initial burden of your promotion case. In a post on his own site about finding a staff sponsor, engineering leader Will Larson lays out who does what for people going for Staff. It's one leader's view, not a finding. As Larson explains, your direct manager controls the packet itself: "They’ll be the person to take your drafted promotion packet and turn it into the company’s format. They’ll be the person to advocate for your promotion during a calibration meeting as others drill into your qualifications."
Your skip-level manager plays a different role in the background. Larson points out that they must at least recognize your work when promotions are discussed: "You don’t need to spend much time with your skip-level manager, but if they aren’t familiar enough with your work’s impact to remember it in a meeting two months from now, you’re unlikely to get promoted into a senior role."
Larson is direct about what happens when your manager leaves:
"Similarly, you might have an amazing relationship with your manager who then leaves the company. You’re hardly doomed, but your promotion clock will likely get reset as you build a relationship with your new manager."
"Likely" is his judgment, not a measured rate, and he notes that the opposite can happen too when a new manager works hard to prove themselves to you by advocating on your behalf. Plan for some delay as your baseline, and treat early support from your new manager as a gain.
Larson also notes that for people who have already done the work, additional checkboxes "are a distraction: what they’re really missing is a sponsor willing to push for the recognition of their existing work." That makes finding out who currently sponsors your case your first priority.
If a committee takes part in promotions at your company, know how much influence they have over your supervisor's ratings. In a 2019 study published in Management Science, Demeré, Sedatole, and Woods examined calibration committees. They found: "Using proprietary data from a large multinational organization, we begin by showing that calibration committees adjust ratings sparingly (i.e., 25% adjustment rate), but when they do, downward adjustments are significantly more frequent and of greater magnitude than upward adjustments."
They concluded that committees help standardize ratings across teams: "Taken together, calibration committees improve the consistency of ratings across supervisors and mitigate leniency bias, but exacerbate centrality bias." But they also found that committees lean heavily on direct supervisors when workers sit further down the ladder: "That is, calibration committees are less likely to adjust the rating of a subordinate who is further removed from committee members in the organizational hierarchy." If a committee exists, Larson's view is that the sponsor who speaks for your work there, "especially to a Staff-plus role", "almost always needs to be your direct manager."
Find out what the old plan rested on, and what the new people think it was
Your agreed promotion plan was an understanding with particular people about particular evidence. It rested on what your previous manager saw, what your former skip-level valued, and how they interpreted your progress. The new reporting chain may read that same understanding differently, and you need to find out how they view it before treating it as dropped. Approach this without accusation, and don't present the earlier plan as something the new chain has to keep.
Supervisors and their staff often disagree on whether obligations have been met. In a 2002 study published in the Journal of Organizational Behavior, Lester, Turnley, Bloodgood, and Bolino examined how supervisors and subordinates perceive obligations. Their study compared supervisor and subordinate perceptions, rather than studying reorgs or new managers specifically. They found that "supervisor and subordinate perceptions are most likely to differ on the extent to which the organization violated its obligations to provide fair pay, advancement opportunities, and a good employment relationship."
When a breach is perceived, the two sides are likely to attribute the cause to different factors: "Specifically, the findings suggest that subordinates are more likely to attribute breach to the organization's intentional disregard for the commitments that it had made to the employee, while supervisors are more inclined to attribute breach to situations beyond the organization's direct control." If your promotion plan stalled, part of the gap may be two readings of the same agreement rather than a plan dropped on purpose. Show your new manager what was agreed and ask which parts they'd count today.
Major restructuring puts these agreements under strain. In a 2023 systematic review in Gruppe. Interaktion. Organisation., Sabine Raeder reviewed studies across several sectors to examine how workplace agreements hold up during transitions. Her review defined major organizational changes as follows: "Major organizational changes involve restructuring in organizations that extends over a long period of time or combines different change events." Across those studies, Raeder found that minor changes didn't provoke a breach, while major changes or downsizing "often led to breaches and violations."
The review didn't focus on software engineering promotion plans, but Sabine Raeder explains where managers fit during restructuring:
"Supervisors often represent the organizational contract partner. They can thus discuss changes in psychological contracts explicitly and address emotional reactions to violations of psychological contracts."
Notice the word "often". Your new manager may not be the person who stands for the earlier plan at all. Ask your new manager directly whether they can speak for the earlier plan, and if not, who can.
Carry your evidence across in a form a stranger can repeat
Turn your past work into a concise written document that outlines your most important output, its measurable impact, and how it maps to the next level's expectations. A useful line names what shipped, what changed because of it, and the design doc or dashboard a stranger can open to check. Walk your new manager through it early in a dedicated conversation, and ask them plainly what evidence is missing for them to argue your case.
Your new manager can only argue for work they can easily understand and explain to others. In an article on staff promotion packets, Will Larson has one instruction for the packet once it exists:
"Continue to review the promotion packet with your manager during your career and performance oriented 1:1s. Both you and your manager should use it to steer you towards demonstrating the promotion criteria over time. This is particularly important to do if your direct manager changes."
The packet is a working record you steer by, not a file you submit once. A manager change is when it has to work hardest, because the new manager may know little about your previous work. Larson shares this advice based on his own experience with Staff engineering roles: "Maintaining this sort of document and reviewing it across managers will help mitigate the loss of progress towards promotion that often occurs after a manager change". He also adds an explicit limit: "It won’t necessarily get you there quickly, and it even might not get you there at your current company".
Writing down your track record helps decision-makers who weren't there to see it happen. In an article on brag documents, engineer Julia Evans shares advice based on her own workplace experience, rather than formal research. She points out that decision-makers simply forget unrecorded work: "It’s frustrating to have done something really important and later realize that you didn’t get rewarded for it just because the people making the decision didn’t understand or remember what you did." When you report to someone new, Evans notes that "giving them a brag document outlining your most important work & its impact will help them understand what you’ve been doing even though they may not have been aware of any of your work before."
Self-advocacy doesn't carry the same consequences for everyone. On her site, Lara Hogan points out that self-advocacy carries uneven risks: "“Talk louder,” “brag about your work more,” “speak your mind,” are all examples of behavior that works when you have a lot of privilege, but carry lots of risk when you don’t." That's why the document should hold facts a stranger can check.
One study suggests why momentum can drop after a manager departs. In a 2022 study in Organization Science, Baek, Bidwell, and Keller studied manager mobility using personnel records from one large US healthcare company. They found that "manager mobility is associated with a subsequent decline in subordinates’ financial rewards but also increased rates of promotion into other groups." When examining the mechanism, they observed that "Comparisons of different performance metrics suggest that our results more strongly reflect changes in managerial sponsorship rather than changes in actual performance."
The authors also argued that these effects would be greatest for people who had worked with the departing manager longer. Their findings come with important limits: the study was correlational, the sponsorship explanation was the authors' interpretation, and the setting assumed managers had "significant authority over subordinates’ rewards and mobility". As the authors noted, "our results might be very different in small organizations or organizations with more centralized reward and mobility practices."
Test the new bar before the review
To find out what your new manager expects in time to act on it, follow this sequence:
- Meet early and walk them through the document from the previous section.
- Ask what they would change about your responsibilities and what specific evidence they would need to see to support a promotion next cycle.
- Show checkable work against that standard across the review cycle.
- Check back before the review to confirm where your case stands.
Writing about how to handle a reorg, Jacob Kaplan-Moss, who comes at it from the side of keeping your job, gives one first move for anyone who gets a new manager:
"If you end up with a new manager: your first imperative should be to begin to build your relationship with them. Don’t wait for them to: try to set up time to meet with them immediately. Brief them on what your job has been to date (if they don’t already know), and ask them right away if there’s anything about your job they’d like to change."
Ask what they would need to see from you to support a promotion next cycle. That's the second half of step 2, and it's the question his post doesn't ask. Don't assume the earlier criteria still apply. Kaplan-Moss adds: "Your performance will be under close scrutiny in the immediate aftermath of a reorg." That early scrutiny is also when your checkable work gets seen, so don't spend the first weeks only describing past work.
If your new manager gives you a vague answer, such as telling you to keep doing what you're doing, don't leave it there. Bring one specific piece of work you completed, ask what evidence is missing from it to satisfy the next level's expectations, and ask who in the company can clarify how the criterion is interpreted.
Managers don't evaluate similar employees identically. In a 2020 study in the Journal of Political Economy, Frederiksen, Kahn, and Lange examined supervisor rating patterns within a single Scandinavian service-sector firm. The study analyzed service workers rather than software engineers, and supervisor differences partly reflected real managerial ability. They observed: "We show that supervisors vary widely in how they rate subordinates of similar quality."
When workers switched supervisors, their evaluation outcomes moved toward the new supervisor's historical habits: "A worker moving from a high to a low rater experiences a sizable drop in pass probability, while a worker moving from a low to a high rater experiences a sizable increase of comparable magnitude." Your new manager might grade more strictly or more leniently than your previous manager. You need to understand their personal grading standard early.
When presenting your work, keep your focus on output others can verify. In the Journal of Management, Den Hartog, De Hoogh, and Belschak studied self-promotion using field data from employee and leader pairs in various professions in the Netherlands. The data was correlational and evaluated existing managers rather than new ones after a reorg. They found that "In line with previous work (Higgins et al., 2003), in the field study, self-promotion was overall unrelated to performance ratings."
The overall null finding concealed differences in manager personalities: "While leaders high on narcissism rated employees who self-promoted to be more important and better performing and rated the quality of the leader-employee relationship to be higher, for less narcissistic leaders, there was no effect." Treat that as a limit of the evidence and nothing more. In my view, the practical lesson is to lean on work the new manager can check - shipped code, architectural designs, technical documentation, and results that peers can confirm - rather than talking about how well you performed. The study didn't test that comparison directly, but verifiable facts leave less room for subjective disagreement.
Remember what asking for feedback accomplishes. In a 2015 meta-analysis in the Journal of Management, Anseel, Beatty, Shen, Lievens, and Sackett evaluated research on feedback-seeking behavior (FSB in their abstract) across workplace settings. They found that "Challenging some of the dominant views in the feedback-seeking domain, the relationship between uncertainty and FSB was negative and the relationship between FSB and performance was small." The point of asking the new manager is to learn their bar, so you don't spend months delivering against expectations they don't share.
What you don't control, and where an outside mentor fits
Some factors sit entirely outside your promotion packet. Ask your new manager direct questions about whether their team has the budget, headcount, and business need for the level you want. You can't out-perform a missing allocation.
In the same Fortune 500 healthcare company, over 2009 to 2016, Baek, Bidwell, and Keller estimate that "a manager move raises the probability of crossgroup promotion in the following year from 6.3% to 7.3%". Those figures are adjusted model estimates across their entire sample, not an observed raw rate, and the data is correlational. The authors also found that "We do not, though, find that managerial mobility reduces the rate of within-group promotion." Manager departures tied to reorganizations were among those associated with higher cross-group promotions.
Working through these changes requires an objective perspective. On MentorCruise, a software engineering mentor works with you directly on your technical progression. As I wrote in the post on who decides a staff promotion, linked above, "On MentorCruise, software engineering mentors are experienced engineers who work with you one-to-one over months. Rather than a one-off call, they establish a working rhythm: live sessions to talk through decisions, async messages between calls to maintain momentum, and direct reviews of the code and documents you're producing."
An outside mentor can't replace internal leadership: "An outside mentor cannot nominate you for a promotion. They don't sit in your company's calibration meetings, and they don't have a vote on your committee." A mentor cannot restore an earlier promotion agreement. What they can do is read your promotion packet cold, the way an unfamiliar manager or committee member will, and point out where your evidence needs strengthening.
On our career mentor page, we explain that "Career mentoring is an ongoing relationship between an experienced professional and someone seeking guidance on their professional development. The mentor shares insights from their own career experience, helps you avoid common mistakes, and provides the kind of candid feedback that's hard to get elsewhere." In those engagements, "Goal-setting is a core activity in most mentoring relationships. Your mentor helps you define clear, measurable objectives and holds you accountable for progress." Some packages include async messaging and detailed feedback on work product. If you want an experienced second pair of eyes to help you rebuild your case, find a career mentor who has evaluated promotion packets and knows what checkable evidence looks like.
FAQs
Should I ask my old manager to vouch for me with the new one?
Yes, if they are still reachable and willing to help. Ask them for a short written handover note or set up a brief three-way meeting that covers what you agreed on and the specific evidence behind it. Having your former manager summarize your accomplishments helps your new manager interpret your past record, but it doesn't bind them to the old plan.
Should I move to another team if the new manager won't count the plan?
It can be a real option rather than a retreat. In Baek, Bidwell, and Keller's study of a large US healthcare company, employee promotion into other groups rose after a manager departed. Weigh that move against the cost of starting your record over with a third manager. Keep in mind that data from one healthcare firm isn't a guarantee of how your company behaves.
How soon after a reorg should I bring up my promotion?
Bring it up in your first conversation, put as a question about what your new manager needs to see, not a request to keep the old plan. The earlier you understand the new bar, the more time you have left in the cycle to meet it.