Over 2,000 mentors available, including leaders at Google, Amazon, Netflix, and more. Check it out
Published

Coach vs. Mentor: Which One Will Help You Find Success?

When it comes to succeeding in your goals, should you hire a coach or find a mentor? Which will help you overcome obstacles and get you where you want to be?

There are plenty of different paths to take to get ahead in life, especially when it comes to career development.

You can go to school and get a degree or start working and saving money to invest in a business. You could work your way up from the bottom of the career ladder or inherit the family business.

But what if you're not sure which path is right for you? Or what if you've already started down one path, but it's not working out how you want it to?

In such moments, you need a coach or a mentor by your side.

These people exist to help guide you down the right path and help you achieve your dreams, but if you're unsure what the difference is between the two, this guide is here to help. We'll be covering the differences between coaches and mentors and discussing which one is right for you.

Let's get into it.

What is a Coach?

Image

A coach helps you identify your goals and then provides you with the professional development tools and resources you need to achieve those goals. A coach will help you stay on track and accountable so that you can reach your full potential.

For example, let's say you want to start your own business.

A coach with the right coaching skills can help you develop a business plan, find the right resources, and connect you with the right people. A coach can also provide you with moral support and motivation when things get tough.

They may also look at your past, where you've come from, and what obstacles you've faced that might still hold you back. This isn't like counseling or therapy, but more looking into how you do things and breaking them down.

If you've shown issues with managing your finances, for example, you might suggest ways to improve your finance skills or point you towards resources that can help. Make sure your chosen coaching focuses on what you're aiming for.

Career coaching is quite a familiar path, but you may actually be looking for something more niche, like improving your public speaking confidence, developing your leadership skills, or focusing on another specific skill. Your coaching sessions can be dedicated to that, rather than just broad coaching services.

However, a coach won't tend to be someone who has already succeeded in the area you're trying to succeed in. Instead, a coach has knowledge and experience in helping people achieve their goals, often acquired by working with other clients or taking specialized training.

Therefore, the best way to view a coach is not as someone helping you achieve your goals because the content of your plan doesn't matter. The goal of a coach is to help you as an individual get to where you want to go on a personal level.

What is a Mentor?

Image

Comparatively, a mentor is someone who has been successful in the area you want to pursue. They could be an industry leader, a CEO, a top manager, or a very influential figure.

If you're looking to get into management consulting, for example, then the best kind of mentor would be someone who's been a successful management consultant for many years and knows the industry like the back of their hand.

A mentor will provide you with advice, feedback, and support as you work to achieve your goals.

Another example would be if you wanted to start a business in the fashion industry, then you might seek out a mentor who has already started a successful fashion business. This person can guide you on everything from which marketing strategies to use to which suppliers to use.

A mentor can also help you avoid common mistakes that new entrepreneurs make.

They may provide you with access to their network of contacts, which can be invaluable as you try to grow your business.

What are the Key Differences Between Mentoring and Coaching?

Image

There are some key differences to think about, differences that will help you define whether you should be working with a mentor or coach.

Coaches focus on helping you develop the skills and knowledge you need to achieve your goals. Again, it doesn't really matter what your goal is; it's more about focusing on how you can develop yourself to reach the goals you're aiming for.

However, getting a coach with experience in your field, from business or fashion to finance or health, has clear benefits.

Coaches often work with clients over months or years, helping them make progress toward their long-term goals.

Mentors, on the other hand, focus on providing guidance and advice based on their own experience. While a mentor can help you avoid making mistakes, they may not have the time or patience to help you develop the skills you need to be successful. Mentorships are often more short-term than mentoring relationships.

Even when it comes down to meetings, a coaching meeting could last anywhere between 30 minutes to an hour, whereas a mentoring meeting might only last for 15-20 minutes.

A coach and a mentor may work with you for three to six months, although many people may choose to continue working together for well over a year.

Who Can Be a Coach or a Mentor?

Image

Coaches tend to be people who have experience working with other clients, perhaps in the form of a consultant or business leader, but usually, they will have taken specialized training or worked with other coaches themselves to hone their skills.

Some coaches will have qualifications or certifications which is not always necessary.

A mentor does not need any formal qualifications, but they must have experience and expertise in the area you want to pursue.

Mentors can be anyone who has experience in the area you're trying to pursue. You might choose a mentor who is already successful in their field, or you might choose someone who is a few steps ahead of you in their journey.

For example, if you're starting a business, you might choose a mentor who has already been through the process of starting and growing a business. Or, you might choose a mentor who is already successful in the industry you're trying to break into.

The Benefits of Working with a Coach

There are plenty of benefits that come with working with a coach.

A coach can help you develop a clear plan to achieve your goals. They can help you identify your strengths and weaknesses, as well as the resources and support you need to be successful.

Coaches can also provide regular accountability to help you stay on track. They can help you troubleshoot any problems and encourage you when you need it.

If you're stuck in a rut, a coach can help you get unstuck and moving in the right direction again and is very similar to the role of a teacher.

The Benefits of Working with a Mentor

The experience of working with a mentor can really excel when you have access to their unique knowledge of your preferred industry. They can also introduce you to their network of contacts, which can be invaluable as you try to grow your business.

Mentors can also provide you with an outside perspective on your business. They can help you troubleshoot specific problems, gain access to exclusive events, and advise you on overcoming challenges.

If you're feeling lost or uncertain, a mentor can help get you where you want to go, take important steps, and allow you to unlock opportunities along the way.

What are the Cost Differences Between a Coach vs. Mentor?

The cost of hiring a coach can vary depending on their experience and location. You can generally expect to pay anywhere from $50 to $75 per hour for a newly qualified coach, with experienced coaches charging up to $200 per session. Many will also offer package deals for scheduling multiple sessions in advance.

Mentors, on the other hand, often provide their services for free since they might be someone in the workplace, a manager, boss, coworker, or someone from an external organization. However, some mentors may charge a fee if they provide valuable advice and guidance.

When choosing between a coach and a mentor, you must consider your goals and what you want to achieve. A coach might be the right choice for you if you need someone to help you develop new skills and knowledge.

However, a mentor could be a better option if you're looking for more guidance and advice in your personal and career development journey. Ultimately, the decision comes down to what you need and what you're looking for to achieve your goals.

How Do You Know If You Need a Mentoring or Coaching Program?

Image

The answer to this question will depend on your goals and where you're at in your journey.

If you're just starting out, then a mentor could be an excellent option to help you get started and avoid making mistakes while pursuing your dreams.

However, a coach might be a better choice if you're looking to take your career to the next level. They can help you develop the skills and knowledge you need to achieve your goals.

Ultimately, it's up to you to decide whether you need a coach or a mentor.

There's no right or wrong answer, and there's no shame in seeking out either type of support. The most important thing to remember is that whatever approach you take, you're taking action and working toward your goals, and you're moving in the direction that you want to move.

Tips for Working with a Coach

Working with a coach can be a transformational experience, particularly if you approach the engagement with thoughtful preparation and an open mind. To make the most out of your sessions, here's how you can effectively collaborate with a coach:

Set Clear Goals

  • Define what success looks like for you and communicate your aspirations with your coach.
  • Establish short-term and long-term objectives with your coach to maintain a focused trajectory.
  • Clearly define what you're working on, whether it's your technical skills or soft interpersonal skills.

Be Open to Feedback

  • Create a space where constructive criticism is welcomed, and use it to foster your growth.
  • Understand that constructive feedback is not personal; it's a tool for personal and professional development. You will get things wrong, and that's essential for your learning.

Commit to the Process

  • Engage actively with your coach and be ready to do the work between sessions.
  • Be consistent with your efforts to practice skills and apply strategies discussed in your performance coaching sessions.
  • Remember to focus on bettering both your personal and professional potential. The two go hand in hand.
  • Work on making sure your coaching relationship is everything it can be and you're actively working on making it better.

Track Your Progress

  • Maintain a journal or log to jot down insights, track your personal development, and reflect on learnings.
  • Regular progress reviews can highlight your journey and spur continued motivation.

Communicate Effectively

  • Ensure you're honest and transparent during your conversations with your coach to maximize their assistance. Be dishonest or trying to be something you're not in your coaching relationships will do you no favors.
  • Good communication helps establish trust and rapport, which are key to a fruitful coaching relationship.

Whether you're casually being coached or opted for an executive coaching program, you get out what you put in. For the best experience, work with your coach, ask them what you need to set yourself up for success and work on your coaching relationship.

The better the experience for both of you, the better the results will be.

Tips for Working with a Mentor

When partnering with a mentor, the wealth of experience at your disposal can significantly impact your career trajectory. Utilize the mentorship effectively with these strategic approaches:

Respect Their Time

  • Prepare for your meetings. Know what questions you need answers to and what guidance you're seeking.
  • Be punctual and concise during interactions to maximize your time together.

Leverage Their Network

  • Don't be shy to ask for introductions if your mentor is willing, but do so respectfully and with a clear purpose.
  • Understand the value of the connections you're being granted.

Apply Their Advice

  • A mentor offers wisdom based on experience. Try out their strategies and learn from trial and error.
  • Feedback loop is essential; discuss the outcomes from applying their advice and what you've learned.

Nurture the Relationship

  • A mentorship isn't just a transaction; it's a relationship that can benefit from reciprocity and gratitude.
  • Appreciate your mentor's contribution to your growth and find ways to give back, such as offering insights into your generational perspective or fresh industry trends.

By adhering to these tips, which apply to both coaching and mentoring relationships, interactions with your coach or mentor can turn into exceptional and enriching experiences, pushing you closer to your personal and professional aspirations.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between a coach and a mentor?

While both coaching and mentoring are beneficial for personal and professional development, they differ in their approaches. A coach mainly helps you develop skills and set goals, while a mentoring program provides advice and guidance based on their own experiences in your field.

  • Coaches often work with you on tasks, skills, and goals, which is very common in life coaching
  • Mentors provide advice and feedback based on their experience in your area of interest

What should I consider when deciding between a coach or a mentor?

Before making a decision, it's essential to consider your goals and what you hope to achieve.

  • If you're looking for someone to aid in the holistic development of your skills and goal-setting, a coach might be more fitting
  • If you need guidance and advice from someone seasoned in your field, a mentor could offer valuable insights.

How much do coaching and mentoring cost?

The cost can vary. Coaching often comes at a price, depending on factors such as the coach's experience. Mentoring, however, is usually free, as mentors typically offer their advice voluntarily.

  • Coaching prices range depending on experience, potentially costing up to $200 per session
  • Mentoring is often free, but some mentors may charge a fee for their guidance

How long should I work with a coach or mentor?

The duration of a coaching or mentoring relationship is variable—it depends on your goals and what you want to achieve. Some people may only need a few sessions, while others may work with a coach or mentor for years.

  • Coaches may work with clients over a series of months to years, focusing on long-term goals
  • Mentoring could be a more short-term commitment, with sessions potentially focused on providing immediate guidance and advice

Either way, focus on relationship building, as this is how you get the most out of the experience. When you and your coach or mentor are on the same team, this is how you'll make real progress.

How do I engage with a coach or mentor on MentorCruise?

Getting started with any of our MentorCruise mentoring programs is simple:

  • Sign up for an account.
  • Browse the available coaches or mentors.
  • Choose one that aligns with your needs.

You can then communicate with your coach or mentor through multiple avenues, such as calls, texts, video chats, and designated tasks. Depending on your choice, you may gain access to exercises, tasks, and more.

Get Started with MentorCruise

Whether you're looking for either a mentor or a coach, MentorCruise can help you find the right match for your needs. We offer access to an extensive range of mentors and coaches, some of whom work in the top companies in the world, including Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Netflix, Stripe, Uber, and so many more.

It doesn't matter what goals you're aiming for, from acing an upcoming job interview, trying to build a startup from the ground up, or looking to progress yourself or your career in any way; our mentors can help you achieve them.

All you need to do is sign up for an account choose a coach or mentor you'd love to work with, and you'll have access to them. Enjoy multiple calls a month, unlimited text chat, video calls, provided tasks and exercises, and so much more.

Get started today and take your career or business to the next level with MentorCruise.

Find an expert mentor

Get the career advice you need to succeed. Find a mentor who can help you with your career goals, on the leading mentorship marketplace.